Alternative Therapy for Interstitial Pulmonary Fibrosis
This article is reprinted with permission from Westie News, published by the
Westie Foundation of America, Inc.,
Fall 2009, pp 8-11.
Michael Ina, DVM
Arguello Pet Hospital
San Francisco, CA 94118
On July 8, 2008, Kalie, a ten and one half
year old, spayed female Westie, was brought in for a routine teeth cleaning, 2
mass removals and chest radiographs. The owners heard her cough in late June and wanted to have her lungs
evaluated for interstitial pulmonary fibrosis (IPF). At this time, she was basically showing no
The radiographs were taken first because, if there was severe
pulmonary disease, we were not going to use general anesthesia for the
dentistry. I read the lungs out as having mild tracheal collapse and mild
interstitial disease (pulmonary fibrosis).
Dr. Sam Silverman, a board certified
veterinary radiologist, read Kalie’s radiographs.
The lungs are increased in opacity and are poorly inflated. The heart is
at the upper limit of normal size. The diaphragm appears intact.
Tracheal collapse may be present.
Interstitial pulmonary fibrosis (IPF) may be present. Mild
tracheal collapse is also suspected. No evidence of heart failure.
- Kalie's radiographs taken on July 8,
2008, at diagnosis, prior to treatment
We tried bronchodilators to treat the collapsing trachea, but
Kalie could not tolerate Theophylline or Brethine (Terbutaline).
On November 11, 2008, Kalie was presented because of increased
frequency of coughing, as much as 3 times a day. On physical exam, Kalie’s
lungs were clear. Radiographs were taken (chemical restraint was not used).
Again, Dr. Sam Silverman read Kalie's radiographs.
The cardiac silhouette is similar in size to the previous study.
The radiographs were made at an incomplete phase of inspiration. No evidence of
severe lobar consolidation or discrete pulmonary nodularity is seen. The
tracheal caliber is mildly irregular. A large amount of gas is present in the
Changes are very similar to the previous study, differences in
the phase of respiration and the lack of a complete inspiration at the time of
radiographic exposure make it difficult to quantitate changes, however,
persistent bronchointerstitial disease is likely.
- Radiographs taken November 11, 2008 following initial treatment with
I had purchased a cold laser unit in October 2008. It was
delivered in November and I had studied how to use the laser unit. The unit I
purchased was the Companion Therapy Laser from LiteCure, LLC. It was a class IV
laser therapy unit.
Kalie’s owner had informed me of a Westie in Carmel, California
that was diagnosed with pulmonary fibrosis and was treated with cold laser. I
contacted the veterinarian, located in Watsonville, who treated this Westie and
he informed me of his treatment protocol. Unfortunately, he never took
radiographs after the laser therapy but he said he had treated the dog 6 times
and the dog became asymptomatic (not coughing) for 4 weeks after the last
treatment. He was in the process of starting a protocol of monthly follow up
The unit that the veterinarian from Watsonville used was an
older unit than mine. I had called LiteCure about treating a Westie with IPF.
The professional services returned my call with the recommendations for treating
a dog with IPF.
On January 5, 2009, I started treating Kalie with the cold
laser unit to the left and right thoracic wall and thoracic inlet. She was treated three times the first week, two times the second
week and once the third. She received a total of six treatments. Kalie’s owner
had told me that she thought Kalie felt better after each session because she
coughed less and was more active.
On February 17, 2009, we took radiographs to compare the lungs
after the laser therapy that were read by Dr. Sam Silverman.
Although the lungs are not completely inflated, they do appear
somewhat more lucent on today’s study. The bronchovascular markings remain
indistinct but are improved in appearance. No evidence of free pleural fluid.
There appears to be an improvement in the appearance of the
lungs compared to the previous study.
- Kalie's radiographs taken on February 17, 2009 after laser
A side note about the radiographs – it would have been better to
sedate Kalie when the radiographs were taken. She may have taken deeper breaths
with sedation. However, because of her pulmonary disease, I was not willing to
take unnecessary risks for the sake of possibly getting better radiographs.
Since February 23, 2009, Kalie has been brought in once a month
for a “tune-up” laser treatment. I listen to her lungs and get a history.
The coughing ultimately did worsen. On May 6, 2009 we tried
Albuterol solution via a child’s nebulizer with no improvement. Kalie was also given one puff per day from a Flovent inhaler. But, again, there was no improvement. The Albuterol and Flovent were discontinued.
Then on May 28, 2009 we added liquid
chicken-flavored Sildenafil (Viagra) which immediately controlled her coughing. A low dose (2.5mg) of Prednisone every 3
days was also added in January 2010.
It seems that high humidity and hot temperatures exasperate the
coughing. Fortunately, in San Francisco we have very few hot days. On these uncomfortable days, the owner minimizes outdoor
activities and tries to keep Kalie as cool as possible with Vornado air circulators. Because of the
possibility that inhalant irritants (house dust) could also exasperate the
cough, Kalie’s owners use a Dyson vacuum cleaner and room air purifiers.
The owners continue to bring Kalie in for her monthly laser
treatment. Kalie’s owner has noticed that for twenty four hours after these
tune-up laser treatments, Kalie seems to be much more active than usual.
Ultimately, due to the owner’s dedication towards Kalie, the
addition of the drugs (Sildenafil and Prednisone) and the laser therapy, Kalie has
been able to maintain minimal coughing, no wheezing and a very good quality of life.
Update October 2013:
Between 2009 and 2013 Kalie did not develop any significant health issues. Kalie has consistently been receiving a laser therapy treatment once per month since 2009. I began using a new 15 watt Laser unit in March 2012.
Kalie turned 15 in April 2013. In August she was diagnosed with hypothyroidism and developed secondary cardiomegaly. Chest x-rays taken in August revealed her lungs were so compressed because of the cardiomegaly that Dr. Sam Silverman could not comment on their status. Kalie began Soloxine medication.
Repeat chest x-rays were taken on September 16, 2013 and were read by Dr. Sam Silverman. Dr. Silverman compared Kalie's lung status on this date to the last chest x-ray taken in 2009.
No evidence of progressive pulmonary disease. Decreased cardiac size most likely due to increased cardiac output due to thyroid supplementation. Persistent main pulmonary artery size. Tracheal collapse. Liver within normal limits.
Update January 2014:
At the age of 15 years and 9 months, Kalie passed away on January 10, 2014. This was 5.5 years after her diagnois with IPF and 5 years after her laser therapy treatments began. Kalie's lungs were clear up to and including her very last breath. Her IPF was not a factor whatsoever. Her demise was due to kidney failure and dementia.